Join The Club Sign Up For Newsletter - CLICK HERE

  • Best Seller

  • Signature Bezel Set Diamond 18K Gold
  • Get Hitched

  • Classic never goes out of style
  • Stack it

  • ... with Cartier Love
  • For the Music Lover

  • Custom Guitar String Cuff Bracelet

Best Seller

Signature Bezel Set Diamond 18K Gold Treat Yourself

Get Hitched

Classic never goes out of style Browse

Stack it

... with Cartier Love Browse

For the Music Lover

Custom Guitar String Cuff Bracelet Buy it

Love Stories

Dana & Zak

My Ring is Beautiful!My fiancee worked alongside Amy to custom design the engagement ring that he gave me, and it is absolutely gorgeous. There was a lot of love and consideration put into the design process by both Amy and my fiancee. When he described his experience working with her, he noted that she truly loves what she does and puts a great deal of attention into the quality of every aspect of her work-she is an artist.The ring is beautiful, from the diamonds to the setting, and I receive compliments on it almost every day. My hand literally sparkles. What a special experience. I couldn’t be happier.


Esther & Symon

Amy designed both the wedding bands for my husband and I. We had under 2 weeks to turn everything around and made it happen! The experience and process was so efficient and delightful. We love our rings and we love how easy Amy made the whole process for us. We'll definitely be going back for other pieces in the future.

custom radiant cut 3 stone engagement ring

Jason & Aly

Amy was a pleasure to work with and did such an amazing job creating my dream engagement ring! She has only the utmost taste level and a great eye. Highly recommend! 

Amy Certilman Custom Jewelry Designer New York

Meet Jewelry Designer Amy Certilman

See What Clients Have to Say

Client Testimonials

I saw an eternity band on the website which I wanted customized into a five-stone design. Amy was a dream to work with, answered my dozens of emails promptly, and was great throughout the entire process. The ring is gorgeous in person!

Umbereen, NYC

It was a wonderful experience working with Amy! She is not only a wealth of knowledge when it comes to diamonds, but was patient and readily available to answer my questions.

Ben L, San Francisco

Making a purchase like this online can be a bit unsettling at first, but that was quickly gone after starting work with Amy. Everything about the process was great. I would definitely recommend Amy

Tim V, Washington, DC

Amy is a joy to work with . She is talented and fabulous. I would use her again in a heart beat!

Brenna G, New York

We are repeat customers of The Perfect Setting because 1) you can't find nicer quality, customizable jewelry and 2) the customer service is impeccable. 

Kelly M, New York City

Amy was fantastic to work with from the start! I came into this project with a vague idea of what I was wanting, and came out with a ring that is far more beautiful than I could have hoped. This whole process was truly "custom,"

Stephen S, Durango, CO

I highly recommend Amy and the Perfect Setting. Her attention to detail and dedication to customer satisfaction helped me create the perfect ring for my Fiancee!

Joel F, New York City

It's really special to be able to have your sentiments articulated through a beautiful piece of jewelry. Though I had several ideas in my head, I found that Amy was personable, gave solid guidance and offered several design options to work with my budget. The sapphire she selected was perfect and my ring is lovely. I am very pleased with the outcome!

Felicia N, Manhattan

I fell in love with a ring I saw online. Never did I dream that the woman who created it would be so amazing with which to work. Amy has made what could have been a stressful experience into so much fun

Kathy H, New Jersey

More About The Perfect Setting

The Perfect Setting offers custom jewelry design, fabrication and personal shopping for engagement rings, diamonds, pearls & other fine jewelry. Owner Amy Certilman studied at the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) for both diamond and pearl grading and will personally select the stones for your new jewelry. She has a 100% customer satisfaction and will help you find the perfect piece of jewelry for engagement, anniversaries and all occasions. Quality, Service and Value are her top priorities. The Perfect Setting ships World Wide. All budgets welcome.

Contact Us

Instagram feed