Skip to content

Contact Us Today for a Cost Free Consultation 516-422-1220

Contact Us Today for a Cost Free Consultation 516-422-1220

Join Us! Sign Up to Receive Early Release Dates and Special Promotions

Join Us! Sign Up to Receive Early Release Dates and Special Promotions
  • Custom Made Gallery
    • Browse ALL Custom Made Jewelry Commissions
    • Browse By Category
      • Rings
      • Earrings
      • Bracelets
      • Necklaces & Pendants
    • Pearl Jewelry
    • For Men
    • Custom Collections
      • Engagement & Wedding
      • Tennis Raquet Collection
      • Pickle Ball Collection
      • Adjustable Shank
      • B & A of Redesigns/Resettings
  • Shop
    • Ready to Wear
      • RTW Hoop Earrings
      • RTW Bracelets
      • RTW Necklaces
      • RTW Earrings
      • RTW Diamond Eternity Bands
    • Semi-Custom Jewelry
    • RTW ALL Jewelry
  • Custom Design Process
    • Custom Made Jewelry - Have an idea?
    • Browse Our Designs for Ideas and Inspiration
    • Redesigns & Resettings B & A Photos
    • Jewelry Box Evaluations
  • Client Reviews
    • Client Reviews
    • Love Stories
    • Creation Stories
  • About
    • About
      • Meet Owner & Designer Amy Certilman
    • Press & Media
      • Amy on The Nate Berkus Show
      • Bella Magazine Feature by Emily Rogan
      • LI Weddings Interview with Amy Certilman
      • Long Islander Newspaper “Gem Consultant Shines”
    • Blog Posts
      • Informational Posts
      • Creation Stories
  • Diamond Education
    • Why Buy with Us?
    • Amy's Jewelry Industry Insights
    • Learn About Lab Diamonds
      • Lab Diamonds 101 - The Diamond Industry Disruptor
      • Lab Grown Diamonds - FAQ
      • Lab Diamonds Regulatory Information - FTC Ruling
    • Buying Diamonds on the Internet
    • Diamond Grading - The 4-C’s
    • Buying Pearls
    • Platinum vs Gold - Is it worth it?

Account

Other sign in options Sign in
  • Orders
  • Profile

Account

Other sign in options Sign in
  • Orders
  • Profile

Your cart is empty

Have an account? Log in to check out faster.

Continue shopping
  • Custom Made Gallery
    • Browse ALL Custom Made Jewelry Commissions
    • Browse By Category
      • Rings
      • Earrings
      • Bracelets
      • Necklaces & Pendants
    • Pearl Jewelry
      For Men
    • Custom Collections
      • Engagement & Wedding
      • Tennis Raquet Collection
      • Pickle Ball Collection
      • Adjustable Shank
      • B & A of Redesigns/Resettings
  • Shop
    • Ready to Wear
      • RTW Hoop Earrings
      • RTW Bracelets
      • RTW Necklaces
      • RTW Earrings
      • RTW Diamond Eternity Bands
    • Semi-Custom Jewelry
      RTW ALL Jewelry
  • Custom Design Process
    • Custom Made Jewelry - Have an idea?
      Browse Our Designs for Ideas and Inspiration
      Redesigns & Resettings B & A Photos
      Jewelry Box Evaluations
  • Client Reviews
    • Client Reviews
      Love Stories
      Creation Stories
  • About
    • About
      • Meet Owner & Designer Amy Certilman
    • Press & Media
      • Amy on The Nate Berkus Show
      • Bella Magazine Feature by Emily Rogan
      • LI Weddings Interview with Amy Certilman
      • Long Islander Newspaper “Gem Consultant Shines”
    • Blog Posts
      • Informational Posts
      • Creation Stories
  • Diamond Education
    • Why Buy with Us?
      Amy's Jewelry Industry Insights
    • Learn About Lab Diamonds
      • Lab Diamonds 101 - The Diamond Industry Disruptor
      • Lab Grown Diamonds - FAQ
      • Lab Diamonds Regulatory Information - FTC Ruling
    • Buying Diamonds on the Internet
      Diamond Grading - The 4-C’s
      Buying Pearls
      Platinum vs Gold - Is it worth it?
    • Custom Made Gallery
    • Shop
    • Custom Design Process
    • Client Reviews
    • About
    • Diamond Education
    Based on 273 reviews
    Write a review
    99%
    (269)
    1%
    (2)
    0%
    (0)
    0%
    (0)
    1%
    (2)
    S
    Soft Flexible Diamond Bangle 14K White or 14K Yellow Gold
    Stacie Palmer
    I love my bracelet

    I love my bracelet. It’s comfortable to wear and looks great I always get compliments when I wear it.

    Soft Flexible Diamond Bangle 14K White or 14K Yellow Gold
    R
    Custom 3 CT Oval Diamond Engagement Ring with Tapered Baguettes - Platinum
    Rachel W
    Our dream ring!

    Amy was a phenomenal support to us on our journey to dream up and create our ideal ring. We really valued her patience, expertise and advice as we navigated the process and ultimately landed on an exceptional piece. Amy is flexible, knowledgeable and honest and we can not thank her enough for everything!

    Custom 3 CT Oval Diamond Engagement Ring with Tapered Baguettes - Platinum
    A
    Tennis Racquet Bracelet Gold Diamond Pearls
    Anna D
    The perfect stack ⭐

    I found perfect setting online and Amy was super helpful and helped me to design something that represented me that I love wearing every day even when I am playing tennis. - I absolutely love this pearl and tennis racket bracelet. Thank you Amy !

    User picture
    Tennis Racquet Bracelet Gold Diamond Pearls
    C
    Diamond Tennis Necklace - Mined Natural or Lab Diamonds - 14K White or 14K Yellow Gold
    Carolyn P
    Carolyn P

    I LOVE this necklace! It’s so beautiful and versatile. I chose white gold and it looks fabulous on its own, or mixed with other pieces.
    Amy is so knowledgeable and helpful. I can’t wait to shop for more of her pieces!

    Diamond Tennis Necklace - Mined Natural or Lab Diamonds - 14K White or 14K Yellow Gold
    L
    Soft Flexible Diamond Bangle 14K White or 14K Yellow Gold
    Leslie L
    This white gold diamond tennis bracelet is absolutely beautiful

    This white gold diamond tennis bracelet is absolutely beautiful. The flexible, oval design fits my wrist perfectly and feels incredibly comfortable to wear all day., in fact I never take it off. The clasp is easy to use, lies completely flush with the bracelet, and never catches on clothing looking seamless and elegant. It’s both practical and stunning, and quickly became one of my favorite everyday pieces.

    Soft Flexible Diamond Bangle 14K White or 14K Yellow Gold
    A
    Soft Flexible Diamond Bangle 14K White or 14K Yellow Gold
    Anonymous
    I never take this bracelet off!

    I haven’t taken this bracelet off since the moment I got it! It looks beautiful and feels so comfortable that I wear it exercising, playing tennis and even sleeping!! Amy was a dream to work with- she guided me to the right choice and I couldn’t be happier. My experience with Amy and The Perfect Setting was absolutely perfect!

    Soft Flexible Diamond Bangle 14K White or 14K Yellow Gold
    M
    Diamond Tennis Necklace - Mined Natural or Lab Diamonds - 14K White or 14K Yellow Gold
    Mary S
    Beautiful Tennis Necklace

    The quality of this Tennis necklace is outstanding! I chose yellow gold for a little bit more casual look and it pairs well with a lot of different necklaces I own or it’s great on its own. Amy was a pleasure to work with and I highly recommend the Perfect Setting.

    Diamond Tennis Necklace - Mined Natural or Lab Diamonds - 14K White or 14K Yellow Gold
    A
    Soft Flexible Diamond Bangle 14K White or 14K Yellow Gold
    Amy B
    love this bangle

    love this bangle.. amazing.

    Soft Flexible Diamond Bangle 14K White or 14K Yellow Gold
    C
    Vivid Yellow Emerald Cut Diamond Ring with Set Baguettes
    Cynthia D
    Pure Perfection!

    Amy has designed a couple of rings for me. With each ring, Amy took the time to understand the exact design I was interested in. Amy brought in multiple stones until I found the exact stone or stones to make my ring perfect. Amy understands the jewelry industry and takes the time to understand her clients wants and needs. Amy will make your design process seamless and enjoyable. I love my rings and receive compliments every time I wear them. I’m sure you will love whatever you entrust Amy to design for you!

    Vivid Yellow Emerald Cut Diamond Ring with Set Baguettes
    C
    3 ct Oval and Hearts Diamond Custom Engagement Ring
    Connor Burns
    Spectacular 3 Stone Custom Engagement Ring With Hearts

    Amy is absolutely incredible at what she does. I had a very general idea of what I wanted for this ring, and Amy came in and curated the ring of my fiancés dreams. Her craftsmanship is exquisite, capturing every detail flawlessly (see heart shaped side stones). The ring is truly a one-of-a-kind symbol of our love. The entire process was delightful, with exceptional professionalism and excellent communication throughout. I highly recommend Amy to anyone looking for the custom ring of their dreams!

    3 ct Oval and Hearts Diamond Custom Engagement Ring
    N
    Ring Setting for Swollen Knuckles and Arthritic Fingers - Adjustable Open Shank
    Norma Atwood
    Best ring for arthritis

    I have owned this band for over 15 years. It opens to fit over my arthritic knuckles and then closes for my ring size. Because of it, I have beg able to wear a wedding ring with my original diamonds on it. It's the best for people like me. Thank you to whoever invented it. The mechanism works beautifully over and over again without fail.

    User picture
    Ring Setting for Swollen Knuckles and Arthritic Fingers - Adjustable Open Shank
    N
    Cushion Cut Diamond Hidden Halo Engagement Ring GIA Certified
    Nicole Quatraro
    I have the ring of my dreams!

    Amy helped design the engagement ring of our dreams, and it came out even more perfect than I could have imagined. Amy is second to none when it comes to knowledge and eye for design. She takes the time to get to know you and understand exactly what you're looking for. I couldn't recommend working with Amy enough, overall great experience and stunning ring!

    User picture
    Cushion Cut Diamond Hidden Halo Engagement Ring GIA Certified
    D
    Megan Markel Inspired 3 Stone Cushion Ring with Lab Diamonds
    Danielle D
    Got exactly what I wanted! Couldn't be happier!

    Amy is absolutely amazing to work with. I knew I was in good hands from day one just consulting with her. She made sure I got EXACTLY what I wanted and was always available when I needed her. She was extremely thorough in the process of designing my absolute dream ring. She worked with me on every single detail from the diamonds to the perfect prongs in the setting. I couldn’t be happier! Thank you Amy!

    User picture
    Megan Markel Inspired 3 Stone Cushion Ring with Lab Diamonds
    l
    7 CTW Emerald Cut Eternity Anniversary Ring Mined Diamonds
    lisa nedell
    Another perfect result!

    I just recently went back to Amy to help with an emerald eternity band for my 25th anniversary- as usual absolutely perfect result - the ring is fantastic - getting compliments everywhere and absolutely love it! Cannot thank her enough for all the help navigating the waters!

    User picture
    7 CTW Emerald Cut Eternity Anniversary Ring Mined Diamonds
    E
    Lab Diamond Bezel Set Rustic Earrings
    Ellen S.
    Despite long distance, Amy was easy to work with!

    Amy made a beautiful and special pair of earrings for me. She was easy to work with, despite the transaction being long distance. She was helpful in explaining options, and supplied several photos of choices. The final product was exactly what I wanted. Her pricing was very fair for custom work. I look forward to working with her again.

    User picture
    Lab Diamond Bezel Set Rustic Earrings
    A
    The Fountain Head Deco Themed 3 Stone Cultured Lab Diamond Engagement Ring
    Alexander Sullivan
    Leave review

    I cannot say enough good things about Amy. Her design and communication skills made the experience of making my fiancée's engagement ring fun and low-stress. I was able to show her pictures of rings that I liked as well as some special motifs that I wanted incorporated, and she dreamed up a novel design that incorporated them all. I've never seen is anywhere else. The ring is a true work of art. She walked me through every step of the process, listening to me while also injecting her professional insights.

    Amy's business conduct is also exceptional. She never made me feel pressured during our initial conversations, and spoke frankly about parameters like budget, design capabilities, and timelines. The clear communication of expectations helped me feel confident throughout the process. There was also good communication at every step along the way.

    In sum, I cannot recommend Amy highly enough. If you need a special piece, The Perfect Setting is the place to go.

    User picture
    The Fountain Head Deco Themed 3 Stone Cultured Lab Diamond Engagement Ring
    J
    Erlenmeyer Flask Custom Opal Pendant
    James Ingenito
    Brought Idea to Life!

    Thank you to Amy for helping bring an idea to life. I wanted to make a necklace with a loose opal that was science themed for my wife. I'm sure an Erlenmeyer flask is not a common request. But, starting with my terrible picture in MS Paint, we talked it out and bounced around different ideas and it came out great. It was my first time trying this and Amy was super helpful and knowledgeable. There's so many subtle things to consider, I'm amazed how it came out.

    User picture
    Erlenmeyer Flask Custom Opal Pendant
    J
    Custom Star Diamond Ring | Handcrafted in NYC | 14K Gold
    Judy Hensley
    Will Cherish For Life!

    Amy is amazing! I wanted to reset an engagement ring. She understood exactly what I was looking for and walked me through the process every step of the way to ensure that the ring would be precisely what I wanted. It exceeded my expectations and I will cherish it for life.

    User picture
    Custom Star Diamond Ring | Handcrafted in NYC | 14K Gold
    B
    Lab Grown Cultured Diamond in Classic 6 Prong Setting
    Brendan Cronin
    Beautiful jewelry and is a pleasure to work with

    I worked with Amy to design a custom engagement ring for my fiance. She both creates beautiful jewelry and is a pleasure to work with.
    Working with Amy was pleasant and efficient. She was very accommodating when I worked with her remotely at the start of our engagement planning, and even went out of her way to meet with me in the city to look at specific diamonds. Very prompt email/text responses, sound advice, great fund of knowledge.
    The ring itself was absolutely beautiful. She provides the highest quality stones and works to tailor the design to all specifications. My fiance and I absolutely love the ring and are very thankful that we found Amy to work with through this process - she made things enjoyable and exciting in what can be an overwhelming and stressful process.

    User picture
    Lab Grown Cultured Diamond in Classic 6 Prong Setting
    D
    Pear Custom Diamond Engagement Ring platinum 18K yellow gold
    Daniel C
    A true professional!

    Amy is a true professional. I came to her with little knowledge of the industry and she made me feel super comfortable and gave me insight into all aspects of the diamond market and ring making process. She was in full communication with my fiance' and I throughout the process and helped us navigate a difficult situation. I would highly recommend her to anyone in need of knowledge and/or custom work. Thank you Amy!

    User picture
    Pear Custom Diamond Engagement Ring platinum 18K yellow gold
    A
    Custom Oval Diamond Halo Engagement Ring | Platinum | GIA Certified
    Adam Zalkin
    A pleasure to work with

    Amy was a pleasure to work with. She did a fantastic job walking me through every step of the process. My fiancée absolutely loves the ring. I couldn’t be happier.

    User picture
    Custom Oval Diamond Halo Engagement Ring | Platinum | GIA Certified
    M
    Modern Deco Emerald Cut Lab Diamond Engagement Ring | Platinum
    Mary Tobin
    Exceedingly Happy!

    So... where to begin...

    Amy saved my life! It seems a bit strong, however, I was searching for a ring for my fiancé who LOVES jewelry and gave me broad parameters. I was also studying for my Bar exam and working full time. In short, I was just shy of fully insane.
    I saw Amy’s work by chance while searching for custom designers and sent her a message. She got back to me later that day and upon hearing my crazy babbling... she politely stopped me by saying, “okay, you sound overwhelmed, let me tell you what I can do.”
    From that point on she was nothing short of phenomenal!!!! She worked with me to find the diamond, design the setting, and take all of the stress off me about the ring, and, delivered a PERFECT product (quickly, since I was chaotic and hadn’t realized the date I desired it by was much closer than I realized)!
    She is extremely knowledgeable, works with you every step of the way, and is just incredibly talented. I cannot say enough about how wonderful the ring turned out or about my experience working with Amy.
    Thank you, Amy! You made two people exceedingly happy & saved my sanity! You are the best!!!

    User picture
    Modern Deco Emerald Cut Lab Diamond Engagement Ring | Platinum
    D
    Classic Round Lab Diamond Engagement Ring Diamond Band
    David W
    Great to work with!

    Amy was great to work with! She was friendly, knowledgeable, and very responsive. Being in the Midwest, I greatly appreciated the frequent updates, videos, and photos throughout the entire process. She worked within my budget and designed exactly the type ring of ring we wanted. My fiancée and I are very happy with the ring and can't recommend her enough!

    User picture
    Classic Round Lab Diamond Engagement Ring Diamond Band
    M
    Lab Grown Oval Diamond Engagement Ring
    M Fusco
    Best buying experience ever!

    First off, Amy is a very nice and easy person to work with. I purchased my engagement ring from her and on our first meeting, she educated me on diamonds and metals and what to look for and what to avoid. This was important to me because I did not feel clueless when I was looking at the different diamonds that were out there.
    I told her my budget, and she presented me with 3 diamonds that were around my budget but not over, that way I could pick what I liked the best. I could not be happier with my experience with Amy and how she really worked with me and my budget (especially since I am still in school). I would highly recommend her to anyone.

    User picture
    Lab Grown Oval Diamond Engagement Ring
    M
    Cushion Cut Lab Diamond with Sapphire Baguettes
    M Williams
    I highly recommend!

    Working with Amy was the best part of the engagement ring process. She was extremely knowledgeable on each part, from how to best set my diamond shape as well as using sapphire gemstone baguettes as an accent. I was also in a bind as I was working with another jeweler who backed out on me, and she was able to deliver the perfect ring to me with plenty of time to spare. My financée absolutely loves her ring and can't stop talking about it.

    I would highly recommend working with Amy for any jewelry needs, especially engagement rings. She's committed to getting you exactly what you want, and shows you designs and processes along the way to make sure you're comfortable.

    User picture
    Cushion Cut Lab Diamond with Sapphire Baguettes
    Subscribe to our emails

    Be the first to know about new collections and special offers.

    ABOUT ABOUT
    • Our Story
    • Blog
    • Client Testimonials
    • Return & Shipping Policy
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact Us
    CONNECT CONNECT
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • X (Twitter)
    • YouTube
    • LinkedIn
    • TickTok
    QUICK LINKS QUICK LINKS
    • Custom Made Gallery
    • Shop
    • Custom Design Process
    • Client Reviews
    • About
    • Diamond Education
    © 2026 The Perfect Setting, Inc
    • Refund policy
    • Privacy policy
    • Terms of service
    • Shipping policy
    Instagram
    Youtube
    Twitter
    Linkedin
    Pinterest
    Customers rate us 5.0/5 based on 273 reviews.

    Search

    Products

    • 18K Custom Yellow Gold Wire Bracelet Lab Grown Cultured Diamonds
      18K Custom Yellow Gold Wire Bracelet with Lab Created Cultured Diamonds

      18K Custom Yellow Gold Wire Bracelet Lab Grown Cultured Diamonds

    • 18K Gold Cross Pendant with Turquoise
      Gold Cross Pendant with Turquoise Gold Cross Pendant with Turquoise

      18K Gold Cross Pendant with Turquoise

    • 18K Hammered Yellow Gold and Sapphire Band Ring
      18K gold hammered ring with sapphires gold sapphire hammered ring band

      18K Hammered Yellow Gold and Sapphire Band Ring

    • 2.5 ct Round Brilliant Custom Diamond Engagement Ring in Platinum
      2.5 ct Round Brilliant Diamond Engagement Ring in Platinum 2.5 ct Round Brilliant Diamond Custom Engagement Ring in Platinum sideways

      2.5 ct Round Brilliant Custom Diamond Engagement Ring in Platinum