What Our Clients Are Saying
From engagement rings to custom designs, our clients share their experiences working with Amy and The Perfect Setting. Each review reflects our commitment to exceptional craftsmanship, personalized service, and creating jewelry that becomes part of your story.
Real Stories, Real Moments
Our client testimonials showcase the journey of creating fine jewelry that celebrates life's most meaningful moments. Whether it's a custom engagement ring, a redesigned heirloom piece, or a bespoke diamond necklace, every review tells the story of collaboration, trust, and artistry.
Why Clients Choose The Perfect Setting
With over 250 five-star reviews, our clients consistently highlight Amy's expertise in diamond selection, her attention to detail in custom design, and the personalized experience that makes each piece truly one-of-a-kind. From the first consultation to the final reveal, we're dedicated to exceeding expectations.
Celebrating Your Vision
We're honored to have helped celebrate engagements, anniversaries, milestones, and everyday moments of beauty. Each piece of jewelry we create is crafted with the same care and precision, whether it's a classic solitaire engagement ring or a completely custom creation.
We're grateful to every client who has trusted us with their vision and shared their experience. Your reviews inspire us to continue delivering exceptional fine jewelry and unforgettable service.
-
Baroque Cultured Pearl on Leather Cord Necklace -
Custom Sapphire and Diamond Ring Expandable Band for Arthritic Fingers -
Classic Four Prong Diamond Engagement Ring -
Resetting - Unworn Diamond and Sapphire Ring to Necklace and Earrings -
Cushion Halo Engagement Ring with Round Diamond Split Shank -
Custom Sapphire and Diamond Deco Inspired Engagement Ring -
Resetting - Wedding Ring Becomes Diamond Disc Earrings -
Cushion Cut Diamond Engagement Ring in Halo Setting with Milgrain -
Resetting - Unworn Eternity Band into Mother Daughter Necklaces -
Resetting - Diamond Bezel Set Necklace -
Turquoise Diamond Three Stone Ring | Bezel Setting | White Gold | Custom Design | Handmade NYC -
Tennis Racquet Bracelet Gold Diamond Turquoise -
Customizable Three Stone Ring | Bezel Setting | Diamond or Gemstone | 14K 18K Gold | Handmade NYC -
Adjustable Shank Band for Arthritic and Swollen Fingers -
Double Strand Cultured Pearl Necklace Custom 18K Gold Clasp -
Custom Aquamarine 18K Gold Removable Pendant -
Claddagh Celtic Knot Ring with Diamond Heart -
Custom Claddagh Ring with Lab Grown Sapphire | Celtic Knot | 18K Gold or Platinum -
Emerald Cut Diamond Engagement Ring with Baquette Halo -
Custom Diamond Engagement Ring Radiant Cut -
Resetting - Unworn pearl necklace to new bracelet -
Pearl Bracelet Macrame Cord -
Akoya Cultured Pearl Bracelet Gold Clasp -
Resetting - Sapphire and Diamond Ring
Not at all — the majority of our clients work with us remotely from across the country. The entire custom jewelry process, from initial consultation to final approval, can be done via phone or video call. Finished pieces are shipped securely and fully insured. Distance has never been a barrier to creating something extraordinary together.
Semi-custom starts from an existing design with targeted modifications — changing the metal, adjusting proportions, or swapping a stone. Fully custom begins from scratch with an original design created just for you. Amy will help you determine which approach fits your vision and budget.
Absolutely — Amy welcomes heirloom stones and can design an entirely new piece around them. She has extensive experience resetting inherited diamonds, sapphires, rubies, emeralds, and pearls into contemporary settings.
Most fully custom pieces are completed within 4–6 weeks depending on complexity. Rush timelines may be available for special occasions. Semi-custom modifications on existing designs can often be completed more quickly.
Custom pieces typically start around $2,500 and range upward depending on design complexity, metal choice, and stone selection. Lab-grown diamonds offer a more accessible price point without compromising quality. Amy works with a wide range of budgets and is always transparent about costs before any work begins.
It begins with a complimentary consultation where you share your vision, inspiration, and budget. Amy then develops the design concept, guides you through stone and metal selection, and oversees production from start to finish. You're involved at every stage with approvals before anything is finalized.