Custom jewelry is at the heart of everything Amy Certilman does at The Perfect Setting. Every piece in this gallery was designed for someone with a vision — and entrusted to Amy to bring that vision to life with exceptional precision and care.

Browse our custom jewelry gallery and imagine what we can design for you. Every piece can be modified or completely reimagined to reflect your personal style, story, and vision. Available as semi-custom adaptations or fully custom commissions.

The Custom Design Process

From the first conversation to the final reveal, Amy guides you through every step of creating jewelry that's uniquely yours. Choose your own diamond or gemstone, design your setting from scratch, or modify an existing design to make it perfect. Whether you're creating an engagement ring, redesigning a family heirloom, or bringing a completely original idea to life, Amy collaborates with you to ensure every detail is exactly right.

See the Transformation

Curious about what's possible? Visit our Redesign & Resettings collection to see stunning before and after examples of heirloom jewelry transformed into modern masterpieces. From outdated settings to breathtaking new designs, these real client projects showcase the art of reimagining your treasured pieces.

Your Diamond, Your Way

We don't keep on-hand diamond inventory — you select your own stone to create a piece perfectly tailored to your preferences and budget. Choose from natural mined or lab-grown diamonds and gemstones, both offering exceptional quality and brilliance. Amy will help you navigate the options to find the perfect stone for your custom creation.

Endless Possibilities

Whether you're drawn to classic elegance, vintage-inspired details, or modern minimalist design, Amy's custom jewelry process brings any vision to life. Modify metal types, adjust proportions, combine design elements, or start from a blank canvas — the possibilities are truly limitless.

Heirloom-Quality Craftsmanship

Every custom piece is crafted with meticulous attention to detail using time-honored techniques and the finest materials. These aren't just beautiful accessories — they're investments in quality, meaning, and artistry that will be treasured for generations.

Frequently Asked Questions

How does the custom jewelry design process work at The Perfect Setting? It begins with a complimentary consultation with Amy Certilman, where you share your vision, inspiration, and budget. Amy then develops the design concept, guides you through stone and metal selection, and oversees production from start to finish.

How long does custom jewelry take? Most fully custom pieces are completed within 4–6 weeks depending on complexity. Rush timelines may be available — contact us to discuss your needs.

Can I bring my own diamonds or gemstones? Absolutely — Amy welcomes heirloom stones and can design an entirely new piece around them, honoring their sentimental value while creating something modern and wearable.

What's the difference between semi-custom and fully custom? Semi-custom starts from an existing design with targeted modifications. Fully custom begins from scratch with an original design created just for you. Amy can help you determine which approach best fits your vision and budget.

Ready to start designing? Call us at 516-422-1220 or email info@theperfectsetting.com to begin your custom jewelry journey.