The New Era of Brilliance: Why I Choose to Offer Lab-Grown Diamonds

Price comparison of a 5-carat natural cushion cut diamond versus a 5-carat lab-grown diamond — The Perfect Setting

As a custom jewelry designer, my primary goal has always been to bring your vision to life without compromise. For a long time, "high-end" meant one thing: natural mined stones. But the landscape of luxury is changing—and I've never felt better about it.

Last week I received an email from a diamond dealer highlighting some exceptional natural mined stones. The prices stopped me in my tracks. I've been offering both mined and lab-grown diamonds since 2019, but never has the price disparity—and the quality gap—been so striking. Here's the email:

Email to Amy Certilman from a diamond dealer showing natural diamond pricing for a 5-carat cushion cut stone

And here's how that same budget compares when applied to a lab-grown diamond of superior quality:

Side-by-side price comparison of a 5-carat natural cushion cut diamond versus a 5-carat lab-grown diamond — The Perfect Setting
5-carat natural cushion cut vs. 5-carat lab-grown diamond: same size, higher color and clarity grades, a fraction of the price.

Luxury Without the Trade-Offs

On one side: a beautiful 5-carat natural cushion cut—a masterpiece of nature, priced at nearly $100,000. On the other: a lab-grown diamond of the same size, with even higher color and clarity grades, for under $10,000—including a custom setting.

Offering lab-grown diamonds feels like a superpower for a designer. It means I can help you put that "extra" into the craftsmanship:

  • Ultimate Quality: We can prioritize D–F colors and VVS clarities that were once out of reach for many budgets.
  • Design Freedom: Instead of compromising on the setting to afford the stone, we can create the intricate, heavy-gold, or multi-stone piece you've always envisioned.

Respecting the Legacy of Mined Diamonds

Does this mean the era of the mined diamond is over? Absolutely not.

For some, there is a profound, romantic history in a stone that took billions of years to form deep within the earth. For many clients, that rarity and story are the ultimate luxury.

Your Vision, Your Choice

Because I believe luxury is about personal choice, I don't keep a inventory of pre-selected stones. My job isn't to sell you what's on a shelf—it's to source exactly what you want. Whether that's a rare, earth-mined treasure or a cutting-edge lab-grown diamond, I'm here to ensure the quality is impeccable and the design is uniquely yours.

Curious which option is right for you? Let's talk—I'd love to help you find the perfect stone for your vision.

0 comments

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.